Aller au contenu
Blog

Updated on

Too Many Positions in Your PEA: Over-Diversification Is a Real Thing Too

There's a lot of talk about the over-concentrated portfolio, but almost never about its mirror image: the portfolio scattered across 35 positions that its owner no longer tracks. Over-diversification is nonetheless a real issue — not because it increases the risk of loss, but because it degrades the ratio between the effort put in and what it delivers. This article explains where the line sits and how to spot it in your own portfolio.

The Diminishing Returns of Diversification

The reduction in company-specific risk from adding positions follows a curve that flattens out fast: the first positions deliver most of the benefit, the following ones deliver less and less. Going from 3 to 8 positions genuinely changes a portfolio's risk profile; going from 20 to 35 barely changes it at all — classic studies place most of the benefit between 10 and 20 properly spread positions (benchmarks detailed in how many positions for a well-diversified PEA).

Beyond that point, each additional position delivers a marginal diversification gain… and very real costs.

What Over-Splitting Costs You

Tracking becomes impossible. Holding a company means, at minimum, knowing what it does, following its results, understanding why it's rising or falling. At 30 positions, nobody does this seriously on a part-time basis. The portfolio becomes a collection, not a set of decisions.

Fees pile up. Every position was bought (and will one day be sold) with order fees. At the scale of a retail portfolio, 30 small positions generate cumulative friction with no corresponding reduction in risk.

Performance converges toward the index — but worse. A portfolio of 35 large European stocks behaves roughly like a European index, but with transaction fees on top and without the simplicity of an ETF. If the goal is to replicate the market, an index fund does it better and more cheaply; if the goal is to select stocks, 35 positions means selection has effectively stopped.

Hidden duplication. Over-splitting often creates false diversification: 5 European banks aren't 5 bets — they're a single bet, repeated 5 times. The position count rises, real diversification stagnates — and it's sector concentration that reveals this (see PEA too concentrated in a single sector).

Signs of Over-Diversification

3 quick questions are usually enough for a diagnosis:

  1. Can you say, for every single position, why you hold it? Positions without an answer are leftovers, not decisions.
  2. Do any positions weigh less than 2% of the portfolio? At that weight, even doubling the stock barely moves overall performance — the position demands attention for a negligible impact.
  3. Has your performance tracked the index closely for years? If so, your portfolio may have quietly become a costly, homemade index fund.

Balance, Not Extremes

The message obviously isn't "concentrate everything": between 2 positions and 35, there's a wide reasonable zone, different for everyone. What both extremes (concentration and over-splitting) have in common is that they're rarely chosen: they result from purchases accumulated without an overall view. That overall view can be rebuilt in seconds with the PEA diversification score: free, no account required, it weights your positions by their amounts and reveals what your statement alone doesn't show.


This article is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute personalized investment advice: the "right" number of positions depends on your situation, the time you have available, and your objectives.

Publisher: Earnnest. The content and the analysis engine are designed and maintained by Earnnest.

Disclaimer: This tool provides an educational diagnostic based on the information you enter. It does not constitute personalized investment advice: the result is identical for an identical portfolio composition, whatever your profile. Investing carries a risk of capital loss. Learn more about our AMF regulatory framework.

Last updated: 2026-07-16