How to Diversify Your Stock Portfolio Without Overcomplicating Your Management
Most retail investors discover concentration risk at the worst possible moment: when a position that made up 30% of their portfolio collapses. Diversifying a portfolio isn't a magic formula against losses, but a way of spreading risk so that no single isolated accident determines your entire performance. When you look at your sector and geographic allocation for the first time (it can be viewed in Earnnest), the question comes up quickly: how many positions to hold, how to spread them, and how far to push diversification without turning your portfolio into an unmanageable mess. This article lays out a concrete, numerical method, applicable whether you invest directly or through a PEA (Plan d'Épargne en Actions, a French equity savings account).
Diversifying Your Portfolio: What Exactly Are We Talking About?
Portfolio diversification means spreading your capital across several assets that don't all react the same way to the same events. The idea isn't to accumulate positions at random, but to reduce dependence on a single scenario: a single company, a single sector, a single region, or a single currency.
Concretely, diversifying your portfolio means answering 3 questions at once:
- How many positions to hold so that each one's weight stays manageable?
- Which sectors and regions to cover so that no single economic cycle drives the entire performance?
- What types of instruments to use (individual stocks, ETFs, bonds) to reach this balance without needlessly multiplying positions?
Portfolio diversification doesn't eliminate market risk: a broad-based crash hits nearly all risk assets at the same time. What it does reduce is so-called "specific" risk — the risk tied to a single company: a profit warning, an accounting scandal, a bankruptcy. It's this risk that a well-built allocation absorbs without putting the entire capital at stake.
Diversifying Your Stock Portfolio: Individual Stocks or ETFs?
Once the principle is set, the practical question plays out differently depending on the instruments chosen.
The Case for Individual Stocks
Building diversification with individual stocks takes time and regular monitoring. Each position represents a specific company, with its own risks: governance, debt, dependence on a single market or supplier. To diversify a stock portfolio effectively, you therefore need to watch not just the number of positions, but also their correlation: 2 companies in the same sector, exposed to the same raw materials or the same customers, can fall at the same time even if they look different on paper.
The advantage of the direct approach is full control over selection and the absence of recurring management fees. The downside is the time needed to properly track 15, 20, or 25 different companies.
The Case for ETFs
An ETF (exchange-traded index fund) replicates an entire index or sector in a single position. A world ETF can thus hold several thousand companies. For an investor who wants to diversify their portfolio without spending hours analyzing every stock, ETFs deliver instant, low-cost diversification.
In practice, many investors combine both: a core of broad ETFs for baseline diversification, complemented by a few individual stocks chosen for a specific conviction. This combination allows for active control over part of the portfolio without giving up the structural diversification an index fund provides.
Diversifying Your PEA Portfolio: What French Tax Rules Require
The PEA (Plan d'Épargne en Actions) is the wrapper most widely used by French retail investors, thanks to its favorable tax treatment after 5 years of holding. But this wrapper has a structural constraint that weighs directly on diversification: only shares of companies headquartered in the European Union (or the European Economic Area, under certain conditions) are eligible.
Diversifying a PEA portfolio therefore requires thinking in 2 steps:
- Diversification within Europe remains possible, and is even recommended: sectors, company sizes (large caps, mid caps), European countries.
- Exposure outside the eurozone (United States, Asia, emerging markets) can generally only be achieved through "synthetic" ETFs eligible for the PEA, which replicate the performance of a non-European index via a swap contract while complying with the PEA's regulatory framework.
Ignoring this constraint is a common mistake: a PEA portfolio made up entirely of large CAC 40 stocks can look diversified by position count, while remaining heavily concentrated in a single economic region and a single currency. Full diversification therefore requires, for many investors, combining a PEA for the European portion with an ordinary brokerage account (CTO, Compte-Titres Ordinaire) for international exposure.
Calculating Diversification: 2 Methods for Finding the Right Number of Positions
There's no universally "magic" number of positions, but the wealth management industry commonly relies on 2 complementary approaches for thinking through portfolio diversification.
The Maximum Percentage Per Position Approach
This method sets an upper limit on the weight of a single position in the total portfolio, often somewhere between 5% and 10% depending on the investor's risk tolerance. The reasoning is simple: if no position exceeds 5%, the total loss of that position (in the worst-case scenario, a bankruptcy) can't mechanically wipe out more than 5% of total capital.
This approach is easy to apply position by position, but it says nothing about the correlation between positions: 10 positions at 5% each, all in the same sector, remain heavily concentrated in risk even though no single position exceeds the threshold.
The Optimal Number of Positions Approach
A second, more statistical approach looks at the number of positions beyond which adding one more stock reduces the portfolio's overall risk less and less (what's known as the law of diminishing returns in diversification). Industry practitioners commonly cite a range of 15 to 25 positions as "sufficient" diversification for stocks within a single major market, beyond which each additional position delivers an increasingly marginal benefit in risk reduction, while making tracking more complicated.
Both approaches (maximum percentage and number of positions) should be seen as common-practice benchmarks rather than absolute rules: they depend on risk profile, investment horizon, and how much time each investor can devote to tracking their portfolio.
Worked Example: The Impact of a Total Loss Depending on the Number of Positions
To make this reasoning concrete, take a €10,000 portfolio and compare 2 allocations against the same extreme scenario: the total loss (-100%) of a single position.
Scenario A: 3 equal positions (about €3,333 each) If one position goes to zero, the portfolio instantly loses about 33% of its total value, dropping from €10,000 to about €6,667. The 2 remaining positions would need to gain more than 50% combined just to get back to the starting capital.
Scenario B: 15 equal positions (about €667 each) If one position goes to zero, the loss represents about 6.7% of the total portfolio, which drops from €10,000 to about €9,333. The 14 remaining positions only need to gain around 7% combined to erase this loss.
This calculation deliberately isolates a single factor (the number of positions) to illustrate a mechanism. In reality, sector and geographic diversification influence the outcome just as much: 15 positions all concentrated in the same sector offer no protection against a shock that hits that entire sector. The number of positions reduces company-specific risk; sector and geographic allocation reduce risk tied to a given economic cycle or region. Both dimensions complement each other and should be analyzed together, not as substitutes for one another.
Mistakes That Limit Real Diversification
3 mistakes come up most often among investors who believe they're diversified when they're not fully:
- Confusing position count with real diversification. Holding 20 US technology stocks only delivers partial diversification: the correlation between these stocks remains high in a sector-wide shock.
- Overlooking currency risk. A portfolio exposed to several regions, but always converted into the same underlying currency at the time of purchase, retains a currency risk that isn't always obvious at first glance.
- Never rechecking the allocation. Diversification naturally degrades over time: a position that performs strongly sees its weight increase mechanically, until it becomes the portfolio's most concentrated holding without a single new purchase having been made.
Conclusion
Diversifying your portfolio isn't a one-time operation: it's a balance to keep watching between the number of positions, each one's relative weight, and the sectors and regions covered. The benchmarks presented here (a 5-10% threshold per position, a range of 15-25 positions) are common practices, not universal truths, to be adapted to your horizon and risk tolerance. Rather than guessing where your own portfolio stands on these criteria, calculate your diversification score for free, with no account and no bank connection required, by entering your positions and their amounts. For ongoing tracking, Earnnest's full diagnostic then lets you connect your broker or import your statement.
This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized investment advice.